Part Two
by Terry Mathews
Your
wonderful book "Daddy's Girls" is the story of two girls--Allison and Cherie--
growing up in a very dysfunctional family. How did the family's dysfunction
affect them?
In any interaction,
there are different levels of forces at work. Allison and Cherie are shaped
by their dysfunctional family, and at the same time help shape it by their
reactions to it. Both feel alienated, but respond to it differently. Allison
becomes introverted and insecure at a very early age because of her fear
that she will be caught in the crossfire of her parents' volatile relationship.
Cherie becomes frustrated and angry and retaliates by giving back more
than she gets. As it is in all our lives, the patterns of dysfunction are
a perfect fit with the lessons each person in the family has come together
with the others to learn.
Your
sister struggles with mental illness. Do her battles mirror those of Cherie?
Cherie is an amalgam
of traits and situations experienced by my sister, myself, clients I've
worked with and other people I've known, heard or read about. (Isn't this
what all writers say?) The framework of the story is similar to what went
on in our family, and the emotional tone is accurate as I remember it.
But all the details are fictional and almost nothing actually happened
as I tell it in the book. Many of the Allison parts reflect my own life,
since she's in my position in the family. Some of the Ruth and Cherie scenes
are mine as well, and some are loosely based on the lives of my sister
and mother, but most are completely invented to develop the character or
atmosphere. Rather than recounting the factual truth, I've tried to share
the insight and compassion gathered from my sister's schizophrenia and
my own work as a therapist to offer an interpretation of mental illness
which comforts me and which I hope will comfort others as well.
Your
take on mental illness is not mainstream. Can you share some of your theories
with our readers?
On the surface, the
events in Daddy's Girls may seem unremarkable, belying the incipient
psychosis, and in a sense they are. There's a fine line between sanity
and insanity, a running monologue (or dialogue or however-many) in everyone's
mind constantly. The content is mostly automatic stuff accumulated throughout
a lifetime of trying to cope with everybody else's stuff. Judging, interpreting,
lusting, plotting, regretting, etc., are only interpretations layered on
top of pure living and feeling. In that sense, we're all crazy. But we're
all sane too. Because at the core, our idiosyncrasies reflect our spiritual
mission, and what we create and learn in our unique lives enriches the
ground of being.
What drives people crazy is a fascinating question. According to the Surgeon
General, one in five Americans will suffer from some form of mental illness
in their lifetime. And each has a family affected by their illness, like
mine was. People with mental illness are stigmatized, mostly because we're
all afraid of how easily it might happen to anyone under the right circumstances.
Traditional treatment focuses on causes, which aren't certain, and cures,
which aren't reliable. It ignores the issue of spiritual purpose, which
I feel is the bottom line in all the circumstances of our lives. If we
consider that everything that happens to us has the potential to teach
us essential lessons in living, then even mental illness can be seen as
having dignity. Experience is the teacher, no matter the specifics. Each
of us is born with an innate sense of why we're here. Our greatest challenge
is to realize the meaning of our lives, and our circumstances are tailor-made
to reflect it.
There are no "good" or "bad" experiences. Difficult situations force us
deep enough to touch spirit and learn what it takes to have a fruitful
life. When we bring our inner processes to light, we can come to terms
with and transform them. In searching for meaning in the tragic, we can
tap into deeper levels of perception that transform our vision of life.
If we open to our psyches as the ground where spirit and personality meet,
we can expand our capacity for love and peace of mind. Mental illness can
teach us to deal with our fear and guilt, and to consider life a metaphor
for the lessons we need to learn, which can make a difference to us personally
and to society as a whole.
I think of mental illness not as a qualitatively different state of mind,
but as a variation in the degree of repression or expression of qualities
we all have. It's part of human nature, which contains and reflects all
possibilities. "Sanity" and "madness" are like different points on the
same continuum, more a sphere than a straight line, around which our psyches
bounce almost imperceptibly in every moment. The difference between "us"
and "them" is in how well we stay balanced in stressful situations without
denying the truth of our emotional experience. That is life's ultimate
challenge. Those who "drive us crazy" actually show us how to get sane,
in that whatever attracts or upsets us shows us what direction to explore
to clarify our mission.
The course of family life touches our hearts and strengthens our resilience
like nothing else, as we play out issues we understand at a metaphysical
level even as they overwhelm and confuse us in our normal operations. Although
everybody in a family (or "karass," as Kurt Vonnegut calls our larger group
of significant others) participates in the development of the identified
patient's personality and illness--it's nobody's fault. The factors that
cause insanity are bigger than individual responsibility. The best we can
do is be honest and intend to love.
If we consider the mentally ill as examples of the wrath of God and avoid
them lest it happen to us, we wish they would fade away and not put the
questions of sanity in our faces. If we treat them as the canaries in the
mine who show us what can happen when we don't or can't manage our experience
in a productive way, we can see them as a stimulus to find how to fulfill
ourselves and our obligations to one another. It's a sorry society that
does not care for its most vulnerable members.
Daddy's
Girls is one of the best 'interior' books I've read since Michael Cunningham's
The Hours. How has it been received?
Extremely well. Besides
winning ForeWord Magazine's Gold Medal for Fiction, many readers say, as
you did, how compelling the story is and how difficult to put down. One
of my students told me it was the first book she'd ever read straight through
to the end. One of the most interesting and gratifying responses from readers
is when they confide in me about mental illness in their own families.
In this way, together, we bring it out of the darkness of blame and shame
into the light of exploration.
Any
plans for a sequel?
I've already started
a file. In the sequel, I'd like to have Cherie recover, and relapse, and
recover again, and in the process to learn about the nature of sanity and
insanity and how to stay balanced and cope with the reality of daily life.
I want Allison to discover how to have meaningful relationships, and especially
an intimate relationship with a man. That man will be the third viewpoint
character, and I'll examine his internal struggle and the interplay between
mental illness and creativity. It will be an interesting challenge for
me to create a realistic male point of view.
What
are you working on now?
I'm working on a book
based on my article "TSurviving a Dysfunctional
Family: Ten Ways to Make Peace With The Past And Createe A New Future."
I've got tons of rough material, and I've polished enough of it to write
a book proposal to pitch to publishers. I'm also teaching classes and seeing
private clients using on that material, which is very rewarding.
Thanks
for stopping by to visit with us. Good luck!
© BookBrowser,
2001 |